ClubRoadster.net banner

HKS Legamax muffler for NC

3K views 2 replies 3 participants last post by  Fresh NB 
#1 ·
There has been a great deal of deliberation by yours truly over muffler selection for the NC.
Primarily, the NC owner is faced with the question - stay with the dual muffler, or go single.
The benefits of the single muffler are obvious - free'er flowing, cheaper, and much lighter.
Greddy offer one, as does Goodwin Racing. Custom is also an option of course.

However as the numerous threads, and Brian Goodwin's tireless development has shown, the 2L MZR engine in the NC LOVES to drone.
It's also a fairly loud engine, with some full exhaust setups seeing +90db at track days.
So any exhaust mods for a road going NC have to be treated with caution.

Initially, I was going to go with a single muffler.
However, after much consideration, and countless threads and You Tube videos, I had to conclude that sound was more important than weight or horsepower.
With a road car, I reason that max HP isn't something I'm going to use all the time.
However sound is something that is always there.

What's more, for a daily driven car, it's a big part of the Roadster experience. So it's important to get it right.
There aren't many aftermarket exhausts getting around on NC's in Sydney yet, so first person experiences were scarce.
I'd heard the Mazdaspeed muffler in person, and was not impressed. Plus the car had an aftermarket midpipe.
Lots of drone at constant throttle.

Meanwhile, I kept coming back to this video (and the one on the HKS website)


So when an owner down in Melbourne decided to part with his near new HKS Legamax, I snapped it up.

Stock muffler on left, HKS on the right:


The muffler install was straight forward, it's just a diff back muffler.
Just a few bolts to undo, and there is a replacement gasket provided in the kit also.


First drawback - stock muffler, 11kg, HKS Legamax: 12.5kg


Looks quite cool though. Sits lower than the stock item, so you can see the twin cannisters.
Some comment that it's too low. Others love it. Looks are a subjective thing.



Soundwise, it's exactly what I am after.
Firstly when you turn the car over, you notice a bit more exhaust sound, and a much lower tone.
On the freeway, at constant throttle, I would say it's maybe 5% louder than stock.
Under load it's probably 15-20% louder.
I think the HKS would be a good muffler for those looking to do further exhaust upgrades on their NC, while wanting to limit the increase in noise to a degree. From what I have heard and read, this would be at the quieter end of aftermarket mufflers available for the NC.
It has a nice low hum up to 3000rpm, the note hardens, and above 4500rpm it develops a bit of a rasp.
Brian Goodwin has said a great deal about the drone the NC makes at 3000rpm on trailing throttle.
Well HKS seem to have pushed it further down - it get's some nice standing waves around 1500rpm.
Not the 'brown note' but close. Only at that rpm though, which is above idle and below cruising speed. Since I rarely sit at that rpm, I never encounter it.

Driving impressions? Well, this is the good part.

Immediately, the 'seat-of-the-pants' dyno pointed to better response through almost the entire rev range.
Throttle response is improved again from when I added the Autoexe intake. In fact I would say it is now where I have wanted it to be. Gear changes are just that bit sweeter now.
Certainly, the sound has some impact on this. But it's no placebo effect.



Basically, I was hoping for better tone, more noise at wide open throttle, and some improved throttle response.
The improvement in pickup throughout the rev range has surprised me.
Sound is great, exactly what I wanted. All in all, a very worthwhile upgrade.


In summary:

Improvements:
- high quality finish
- better throttle response
- noticeably better pickup through 2000-5000rpm
- deeper tone, more noise on wide open throttle
- not much louder than stock at cruising speeds.

Compromises:
- blingy (not the most discreet muffler for the NC lookswise)
- 1.5kg heavier than stock
- $$$ when buying new
- compression/vibration at 1500rpm on load or trailing throttle
- sits low - if you scrape your stock NC muffler, this is not for you.
 
See less See more
1 5
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top